Let’s say:
- I am on instance A.
- I browse on a community that is on instance B
- a user from instance C post something on that community B.
Now i want to share a link to this post. Which instance should i pick?
- A my home instance
- B the community
- C the post author
I agree with the other answers here, however if you share the link to another fediuser outside of the platform (e.g matrix) I really like sharing with threadiverse.link.
Edit: an example using your post with threadiverse link (used my local instance to copy the post): https://threadiverse.link/sopuli.xyz/post/29845043
You set your instance once into the cookies and it will always redirect to yours.
@aeharding@vger.social could you add threadiverse support?
That’s useful thanks for sharing.
It feels like there should be something like that built into Lemmy and I was a bit surprised there isn’t, just like how you can link to a community for example with !fediverse@lemmy.world
use the fediverse icon to get the canonical link to a post (which is option C in your list), you can right click it to copy the link
on piefed.social it’s in the overflow menu:
on Lemmy it’s just the icon
although sometimes I do not grab the canonical link, like if the instance is slow or has poor downtime, I’ll use link A or B from your list
(someone should maybe add this info to the Lemmy docs https://join-lemmy.org/docs/introduction.html idk if piefed has similar docs)
That was surprising. I thought like many others that the posts belong to the community. Actually it is not like you have proven.
Do you know an easy way to retrieve link B? As a piefed.ca user viewing a piefed.social post on a lemmy.world community, I see no easy way to retrieve the lemmy.world link. If no easy way exists, then I guess it settles the B vs. C debate.
Do you know an easy way to retrieve link B?
At this moment the web interface doesn’t support this.
I use the app Voyager on my smartphone. I can set in the settings that the share link target links to A, B, C by default or that the app asks me everytime.
More confirmation that C is the canonical URL. Check the <head> section in the HTML (bottom of the screenshot)
Remember that posts belong to users, the community only does a retweet/boost of the post.
More info: https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy-ui/issues/1418
This is why it’s the link provided by the fediverse icon on Lemmy, and the “View original on…” link in PieFed. On Mbin it’s the “Open/Copy original URL”
In my opinion I always do that original instance the post was on.
Id pick the communities instance because that’s the one responsible for federating the post and comments. Id only choose the instances a or c if b is or is planning to shutdown, or if I really wanted to show people what my home instance is
